Skip to main content

Bankruptcy Tourism & UK

The term ‘bankruptcy’, defined as a procedure by which debtors obtain financial relief and undergo a judicially supervised liquidation of the debtor's assets for the benefit of creditors. It is also known as a state of a person who has been adjudged by a court to be insolvent. Then the court orders the compulsory administration of a bankrupt’s affair so that his assets can be fairly distributed among his creditors. Whereas, the term ‘Bankruptcy Tourism’ refers to a process by which both, corporation and individuals (more oftenly foreign) publicize their insolvency in the jurisdiction of their choice.[1] Alternatively, the terminology is also known as ‘forum shopping’.[2]

The law of insolvency varies country wise. Because of that the debtors wish to choose the place of their choice to declare their bankruptcy aiming to take advantage of the most lenient law of insolvency. By doing so they abuse the legal system of that country and get rid of the creditors.   

In particular, the law of the United Kingdom (UK), with respect to insolvency is more attractive as compare to other European countries. Therefore, the foreign bankrupt entities choose the English territory and its legal system as their preferred destination to avoid creditors.

Famously, the legislation and also the interpretation of the Courts in the UK has made a soft impact on the foreign debtors to allow them to go debt free in a short period of time. It is claimed that in term of jurisdiction, the English legal system is of ‘acquisitive nature’.[3] The nature of the English insolvency law is so liberal that it provides discharge of debtors in a very short period of time as compare to other countries.

In practice, it is no surprise to see the English courts to form verdicts in favour of debtors who come from abroad. Consequently, the bankrupts make long queues to knock the door of English Court, thus, it has made the English courts quite busy to resolve those matters. The situation is described as ‘flooding’ the English Courts by the foreign debtors; at the same time distressing the creditors.[4]

Therefore by contrast, the English legal system for bankruptcy faces criticism for attracting bankrupt companies and individuals. Also, it is alarming for courts and insolvency services providers that the abuse of this mechanism must be addressed. At the same time there is also a need to review the law relevant to bankruptcy as well as the practice of the Courts, as how the decisions in those matters tends to favour the bankrupts.




[1] Bryan A. Garner, Black’s Law Dictionary (9th edn. West 2009) 166A Dictionary of Law (7th edn, Iphone version 2.1.477, OUP 2009)
[2] Amy Coburn, ‘The growth of bankruptcy tourism in the United Kingdom’ [2012] II 8
[3] Irene Lynch Fannon, ‘Bankruptcy tourism – why and how?’ (2006) II 26(6) 85
[4] David Milman, ‘Corporate insolvency law: the drivers for litigation and reform’ (2011) CLN 292 1

Comments

  1. Unknown30 September 2015 at 01:09

    Usually when we see the kind of outcome things are having it can all be quite much appealing and surely 2 days tour from new york would be working ahead and taking things to another way for us that makes a mark and helps us in all the terms.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Oman's oil deficit - need to diversify

The Sultanate of Oman shares borders with Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates and Yemen; the country also shares marine borders with Iran and Pakistan. Geographically, it is held on the mouth of Persian Gulf; besides, the Sultanate is also the second largest territory in the Arabian Peninsula. Thus, its physical location and peaceful political situation attract to invest in Oman and offer a convenient place to enhance trade and business relations. It contrast to the excellent opportunities in trade and business. Oman is an oil rich monarchy, which heavy rely on its hydrocarbon resources, mainly oil and gas. Historically, the first ever oil discovery was made in 1956. Later, the first commercial oil discovery was achieved in 1962 and thus, the first ever export of oil cargo was made in 1967. It was accounted that by 2009, in Oman there were more than 135 oil producing fields, which rapidly reached the mark of 162 by 2013. According to the Ministry of Finance, Oman, in the year of 20...
Post a Comment
Read more

The six major non-corporate cases of 'Bankruptcy tourism' in the UK

 1.  Skjevesland v Geveran Trading Co Ltd (No.4) [2002] EWHC 2898 (Ch) The case was about a Swiss banker,  (1)  who had ordinary residence in the UK, because he resided there for 92 days a year; (2)  he had a flat in London to satisfy the fact that he had a place of residence in the UK;  (3) however, his 90% of the economic interests were in Switzerland.  It was held that his ‘Centre of main interest’ (COMI) is outside EU, and the Regulation was not applicable. 2. Staubitz-Schreiber, Re  (C-1/04) [2006] ECR I-701 It was upheld by the European Court of Justice that the COMI to be determined at the time when the debtor lodges a petition for insolvency proceedings and not after that. Therefore, once jurisdiction is established, it is unlikely for a debtors to change COMI.  3. Stojevic v Official Receiver [2007] BPIR 141 It was held that the principle COMI of a natural person is the place where he has his habitual resid...
Post a Comment
Read more